TV Drama Representation Of Disability
TV drama is very stereotypical in its representations of
different groups of people. An example of this is disability, there are many
stereotypes that are commonly followed within TV drama of disabled people.
Although, disability is a rare thing to see in TV drama it does in fact occur
and the disability has meaning and impact within the drama. The characters that
are disabled are alienated from other characters and the disability is a large
part of their storyline therefore ruling out the possible chance that a
disabled character could appear 'normal'. A clip I have analysed involves a
disabled man, 'Nick', that is represented to conform with stereotypes of
disabled people, the use of camera shots, angles, movement, editing, sound and
mise en scene all contribute to establishing this character as failing to 'fit
in' with 'the norm' of society.
The clip opens with a shallow focus shot of a metal fence,
this instantly connotes a feeling of being trapped and mirrors the need for
escape. In relation to disability this could infer how a being disabled limits
the actions of a character and how it can effect the person mentally as they
feel scared and trapped. This interpretation conforms to the stereotype that
disabled people are unable to participate in every element of everyday life as
there are many obstacles in their way. The fence suggests prison therefore
embeds disapproval from the audience and when the disabled character is
presented the audience create a perception that this character must be lawless,
sinister or evil therefore this representation conforms to stereotypes in
society. Alongside this opening shallow focus shot is diegetic sound, voices of
men can be heard-accompanied by the image of an out of focus yellow high-vis
vest in the background- suggests that they are on a building site. This normal
life situation juxtaposes the initial emphasis of being trapped to highlight
the way disabled people are alienated in society and stand out among the
masses.
A following shot doesn't reveal the visually shocking
disability of 'Nick', instead it focuses on capturing his peers reaction by
using a close up shot. This highlights the unease with disability in society.
Disability is stereotyped as pitiable or pathetic therefore the reaction of his
peer reflects that seeing 'Nick' is a chore and his company lacks enjoyment.
The clip constructs a representation that disabled people are a burden and
don't blend with society with ease. The diegetic sound of mens voices is muted
slightly as the editors use sound perspective/aural perspective to emphasise
the separation between the two characters, this connotes the divide in society
therefore places the character with disability in a lower status than his peer.
Also, the clip uses shot-reverse-shot once the disabled characters 'mate'
starts a conversation with him, this is used to portray the way his 'mate' acts
towards him and reflects that he feels uncomfortable through his avoidance of
eye contact. This forms a clear representation that disability is an awkward
and slightly taboo situation as many people feel uncomfortable in the presence
of a disabled person due to feeling pity but not wanting to patronise.
Cross-cutting editing is shown between 'Nick' leaving the
building site and going to help a woman with her shopping bags. This reflects
the continuous hard time 'Nick' has in day to day life, it emphasises the
stereotype that disabled people are their own worst enemy; 'Nick' gets
frustrated when things happen that relate to his disability yet it's his facial
disfigurement that is causing the reactions and situations. It is clear that
'Nick' is working class from his clothing and this is reinforced through the
scene where he attempts to help a lady with her bags, she lives in a row of
council houses and her children are shown with typical 'council estate'
haircuts. This portrayal of working class people constructs a representation
that disability is of lower status in society. A long shot reveals a street
empty of people apart from the woman and her children, the scream she lets out
when she seeing his facial disfigurement reflects the representation that a
male with a disability is non-sexual. The TV drama is lifelike and the make-up
that creates the disability on 'Nick' is very realistic to highlight that this
is the way disabled people are treated. A hand held camera is used to produce a
naturalistic effect, it can also reflect 'Nick's' anger at the way others treat
him and act around him, this supports the stereotype that disabled characters
are aggressive and violent furthermore they lack trust and are objectified to
be an element of curiosity. This scene closes with non-diegetic sound, music of
drums builds up and a sound bridge continues the intense music onto the next
scene for a sense of continuity.
A shallow focus mid shot is used to show 'Nick' walking down
a crowded street. This is followed by a series of short mid shots that contain
strangers in the crowd looking at him. Paired with these shots is synchronous
sound- intense music of drums(non-diegetic sound) over fast paced editing shots
of a busy crowd and 'Nick' walking rapidly- to build tension and suspense
within the clip. This sudden change of atmosphere, created by the music, forms
a representation that disabled people are unpredictable, aggressive and not
very friendly or approachable. The mid-shots of strangers create a connotation
that disabled people are an object of curiosity and interest therefore the
representation made within this TV drama conform to stereotypes of disability.
The final scene within the clip I've analysed features
'Nick' and 'the sergeant' in an open office environment. There is a long shot
that effectively grabs the main focus to notice the army painting directly
above the main characters head, this
connotes that Nicks injury was caused in the army. Also, within this scene
there is only diegetic sound of the two characters talking, the flow of
conversation is not interrupted to suggest that the struggles and pain 'Nick'
feels about his disability cannot easily be helped. Shot-reverse-shot shows how
'the sergeant' doesn't look very sympathetic towards 'Nick' but more burdened
by him. This supports stereotypes of disability in society. The use of diegetic
sound, the footsteps, in this scene creates normality therefore builds upon the
idea of alienation and difficulty of fitting in for a disabled person.
Although, the clip is solid in conforming to stereotypes of disability there is
a side profile shot that challenges the expected representation. The side
profile shot of 'Nick' hides his disability and deceives the camera to see a
'normal' person. However, this contrasts with the close up used to highlight
the characters anger and reinforce the representation that he is his own worse
enemy.
The clip shows a strong negative representation of
disability that conforms to stereotypes of disabled people, for example;
pitiable, pathetic, a burden and unable to easily participate in everyday life.
This extract constructs a representation of disability through a variety of
shots to build a general atmosphere and reaction to the disabled character. It
is also prominent to the audience that the character is very unhappy with his
situation, this is shown through the music and range of shots to show the
characters emotions. The media hugely exploits stereotypes because the audience
feel familiar with these representations, therefore a disabled character that
conforms to stereotypes is more widely accepted and understood by the audience.
No comments:
Post a Comment